Wednesday, January 2, 2013

Kenya's version of Institutional independence


In the early 90s with the clamor for multiparty system, donor aid stopped, Moi government acquiesced to pressure. Parliament and senior civil servants got some autonomy. However, while in principle it was an improvement, it was susceptible to political manipulation and it created distortions in public sector pay. Members of parliament and ministers’ salaries were de-linked from civil service and have enjoyed the largest pay increase. 

With the reforms, parliament was empowered at the expense of other institutions. The result is a parliament that is not accountable though directly elected, members can vote down any law without risking any party censure, and defect without needing to seek mandate. Consequently, parliament has failed to capture the public’s imagination. 

Equally, public servants with political influence – such as top civil servants, the judiciary, and officials in charge of special commissions and semi-autonomous agencies – were granted large selective increases, while the bulk of employees continue to receive modest remuneration. These bodies are insulated from societal influence by virtue of their status and mandate, but it also limits the oversight and accountability functions that should be done by the legislature and civil society. A quid pro quo between the various institutions that are meant to monitor each other exists, judges are called to head commissions and inquiries with ample pay, senior civil servants liaise with ministers, agencies like anti-corruption unit and human rights watch are headed by lawyers sourced from civil society. 

Office holders started differentiating themselves from the rest of society with entitlements and special privileges, e.g. elected officials fly first class on public funds, they’ve sought to increase their per diems to $1,000 per day while traveling and when asked to pay tax on the allowances they pillage government funds to offset the tax bill with the tacit approval of tax commissioner. 

Institutional independence without underlying standards and managed expectations only perpetuates impunity.

No comments:

Post a Comment